Richmond’s draft choice: Butler first or Van Hattum?
Richmond landed Butler, Teixeira and Van Hattum in the final 15 November run, but the result depended on an extra early pick and other clubs passing on the tall. It is an attractive scenario, not evidence that waiting is risk-free.
Context: analysis of simulated selections and hypothetical trades, not agreed club deals or confirmed recruitment intentions.
The decision is about the next pick as well as the first
On 12 November, SotaramAFL preferred taking Harry Van Hattum before Arki Butler. The argument was about availability: Melbourne could choose the ruck/key-forward before Richmond’s next turn. Taking the tall first would remove that particular risk, with Butler still a possible later option.
The completed first-round board from that stream placed Van Hattum at 4 and Butler at 7 for Richmond. That outcome supports the sequence as a workable simulator path. It does not establish how Melbourne ranks either player, and the later reset experiments in the same stream should not be merged with that completed board.
The final November run changed Richmond’s opportunities
The final 15 November run tried the other direction. Butler went to Richmond at 4, Teixeira followed at 7, and Van Hattum remained available at 10. Richmond had acquired Gold Coast’s early pick in a hypothetical trade using future capital, giving it three early selections rather than the same two-choice problem from the earlier board.
That extra choice matters when judging the outcome. Richmond did not simply reverse two names and get a free third player. It spent assets to create another opportunity, while Melbourne chose Tyson Bradley and Sydney moved to Clancy Snell after a matched Ethan Matthews bid. Those decisions allowed Van Hattum to slide.
SotaramAFL still said Van Hattum made sense at the earlier Richmond choice when taking him at 10. The final result therefore records a successful experiment in waiting, alongside the earlier warning about what another club could do.
Butler’s role shaped the combine discussion
Earlier on 15 November, SotaramAFL argued that Butler’s endurance result should be considered in the context of a creative half-forward role. The view was that his ability to influence contests and create scoring opportunities mattered, while endurance could develop over several preseasons. That is an editorial projection, not a guarantee about his development or an independently sourced test result.
SotaramAFL also acknowledged on 12 November that the comparison with Heath Mellody came from the highlight packages watched, rather than a claim to have reviewed every game. That limit matters: a preference formed from those clips should not become an absolute judgement of either prospect’s full season.
17 November: a different board, the same Van Hattum question
On 17 November, SotaramAFL reconstructed Cal Twomey’s top 30 in the simulator. In that exercise, Richmond finished with Butler, Teixeira and Jackson Philips, while Collingwood took Van Hattum. Those are selections attributed to the phantom draft being reviewed, rather than a newly completed set of SotaramAFL’s own preferences.
SotaramAFL questioned Richmond moving away from Van Hattum, describing the tall as an important need while acknowledging uncertainty about the club’s developing options. That reaction continues the earlier availability argument. It should not be presented as evidence that Richmond itself plans to choose Van Hattum. The separate reset and trade experiment later in the stream is also distinct from the saved top-30 reconstruction.
How to test Richmond’s options fairly
Keep the starting order and other clubs’ preferences fixed for a first comparison. Take Van Hattum first in one version and Butler first in another, then record who is available at Richmond’s next pick. If Melbourne or Sydney changes its selection, state that change instead of attributing the whole difference to Richmond.
Run the extra-pick trade as a third version. Compare both the players acquired now and the future assets spent. The decision is whether that fuller package improves the rebuild enough to justify the cost; a three-player result cannot answer that question by itself.
Follow the prospects and club options
Arki Butler · Harry Van Hattum · Gus Teixeira · Heath Mellody
Read the current written 2026 AFL mock draft, the bidding guide or check the points calculator.
Make your own AFL mock draft ↗Simulator walkthrough →
Sources: video dates and timestamps
Sources are SotaramAFL’s completed “AFL MOCK DRAFT LIVE! You Choose The Picks!” livestreams. Dates refer to broadcasts; this article was published on 17 November.
- 12 November 2026 · 3:12 — Why SotaramAFL preferred Van Hattum first
- 15 November 2026 · 7:28 — Butler’s role and the endurance discussion
- 15 November 2026 · 1:16:55 — Testing Richmond’s extra early selection
- 15 November 2026 · 1:22:13 — The final Butler–Teixeira–Van Hattum sequence
- 17 November 2026 · 15:38 — SotaramAFL questions Richmond passing on Van Hattum in the reconstructed phantom
Automatic transcripts were used as review aids and checked against video frames and prospect records. The 17 November audio was transcribed locally because YouTube captions were unavailable; the final 15 November board was checked separately. Other chat suggestions use generic attribution when an exact displayed public username was not verified. Current app settings may produce different results.
More from the livestreams
GWS, Matthews and Steed: what trading for pick 12 changes
Follow two separate GWS scenarios from SotaramAFL’s 15 November live: Matthews before Steed, Steed before Matthews, and the Port pick-12 trade behind them.
Read the analysis →A viewer’s three-way trade: Richmond, Port and Gold Coast
Unpack @matttigers791’s livestream trade proposal: Richmond splits pick 2, Port moves up for a Cochrane match, and Gold Coast adds a 2028 second.
Read the analysis →West Coast’s draft options: Mellody, Elliott and the tall-forward question
SotaramAFL reacts to West Coast’s haul while reconstructing Cal Twomey’s top 30: Mellody, Elliott, Spawton-Guy, and George Gale as a preferred alternative.
Read the analysis →