SotaramAFL · Livestream analysis

GWS, Matthews and Steed: what trading for pick 12 changes

Source streams: 15 November 2026 · 17 November 2026 · Published and updated: 17 November 2026

GWS finished both 15 November runs with Ethan Matthews and Leo Steed, but secured them in a different order. The useful comparison is the whole haul, matching cost and assets traded away, rather than the number on the acquired pick.

Context: analysis of simulated selections and hypothetical trades, not agreed club deals or confirmed recruitment intentions.

Why the Port trade comes before the Cochrane match

SotaramAFL tested GWS acquiring Port Adelaide’s pick 12 for picks 20 and 26 plus a future second-round selection. This was a simulated deal discussed on the stream. Although SotaramAFL referred to external reporting while introducing it, this article does not independently establish negotiations or an agreed trade.

The timing was central to the exercise. SotaramAFL noted that Port could lose access to pick 12 when matching the Cochrane bid. If that selection is part of the matching package, a later trade cannot use it as though it still remains in Port’s hand. The trade therefore has to be assessed before the match and then checked again afterwards.

Port’s side of the experiment trades some immediate matching flexibility for other selections and a future asset. That can change its deficit. GWS’s side brings an earlier pick into a hand that still has to cover an uncertain Matthews bid. Neither club’s result can be judged from the acquired pick alone.

The earlier saved run took Steed before Matthews

In the earlier two-round run, the discussion explored bidding on Caylen Murray before committing GWS’s next open choice. The idea was that a matched Brisbane bid would change the position and matching price of later selections; an unmatched bid would instead leave the bidding club with Murray. That possibility is a real part of the scenario’s cost, rather than a harmless administrative move.

The saved run eventually gave GWS Steed and Matthews, with Steed taken first. SotaramAFL revisited that pair while reviewing the completed results around 1:04–1:06, and then reset the board. Those selections are evidence for that run, not additional players to attach to the final first-round edition.

The final run matched Matthews first

In the final run, Sydney called Matthews at pick 8. GWS matched using its altered hand, and Sydney then selected Snell at 9. GWS later added Steed at 14. The completed Results screen confirms Matthews at 8 and Steed at 14.

The pair is the same, but the route differs. The final run tests whether GWS can secure its tied prospect first and still retain an open choice for Steed. The earlier run tests taking the open player before the later tied-player decision. Their matching packages and remaining pick positions should be read separately.

17 November: check whether the acquired pick survives the match

While reconstructing Cal Twomey’s top 30 on 17 November, SotaramAFL questioned how a later GWS open selection lined up after the Matthews bid. The concern was that the acquired Port pick had already been consumed in matching Matthews, alongside another Giants pick. Simply leaving the club at the old pick number would overlook that consumption and the reordered board.

SotaramAFL manually changed the next club to GWS to continue the reconstruction, while saying the sequence was not computing in that simulator run. That intervention is part of the evidence: it is not a naturally produced matching outcome, an independently verified correction to the original phantom, or a new completed community draft. The reconstructed GWS pair was Matthews and George Dimer, separate from the Matthews–Steed scenarios on 15 November.

This reinforces the practical check: after executing a trade and matching a bid, inspect the actual remaining hand before assigning another player to an assumed pick. If a reconstruction needs manual ownership changes, identify them when presenting its result.

What if Matthews is called much earlier?

At about 6:20, SotaramAFL also tested a Matthews bid at pick 3 and asked whether Matthews plus the remaining selection was preferable to keeping two open choices. That is a different question from a bid at 8: earlier bids can consume a different package and leave a different next selection.

For your own version, save the same starting hand and vary only the Matthews bid position. Record the player retained, picks consumed, any deficit and the next open selection. Then ask who is actually available there. A points total is useful input, but it does not by itself decide which two-player outcome is better.

Use the current bid-matching calculator for a fresh scenario. The November stream’s displayed numbers are historical simulator outputs, and should not be treated as current official club holdings or a promise that later rule settings will reproduce them.

Follow the prospects and club options

Ethan Matthews · Leo Steed · Caylen Murray · Dougie Cochrane

Greater Western Sydney · Port Adelaide · Sydney · Brisbane

Read the current written 2026 AFL mock draft, the bidding guide or check the points calculator.

Make your own AFL mock draft ↗Simulator walkthrough →

Sources: video dates and timestamps

Sources are SotaramAFL’s completed “AFL MOCK DRAFT LIVE! You Choose The Picks!” livestreams. Dates refer to broadcasts; this article was published on 17 November.

Automatic transcripts were used as review aids and checked against video frames and prospect records. The 17 November audio was transcribed locally because YouTube captions were unavailable; the final 15 November board was checked separately. Other chat suggestions use generic attribution when an exact displayed public username was not verified. Current app settings may produce different results.

More from the livestreams