West Coast’s draft options: Mellody, Elliott and the tall-forward question
SotaramAFL questioned the balance of a West Coast haul containing Mellody, Archie Elliott and Harvey Spawton-Guy, and preferred the possibility of George Gale reaching a later pick. These were reactions to a reconstructed phantom draft, rather than SotaramAFL selecting that trio.
Context: analysis of simulated selections and hypothetical trades, not agreed club deals or confirmed recruitment intentions.
Start by separating the selections from the reaction
The 17 November livestream opened with SotaramAFL explaining that Cal Twomey’s phantom had been released and would be tested in the simulator. The saved scenario was visibly named “Cal Twomey Top 30 Mock”. West Coast’s selections in that reconstruction were Heath Mellody, Archie Elliott and Harvey Spawton-Guy. They must not be described as a fresh set of SotaramAFL’s own three choices.
The distinction matters because SotaramAFL did not endorse the entire haul. During the recap, the reaction centred on the roles being added and whether the later selections addressed the most useful needs. This article records that analysis of the simulator exercise; it does not independently confirm the original phantom’s reporting or West Coast’s recruitment plans.
Mellody received a qualified response
Early in the run, SotaramAFL expressed reservations about the top-five selection based on the highlights watched. During the final club recap, Mellody was the part of the haul SotaramAFL was more comfortable retaining. Both moments belong in the account: the later response should not erase the earlier caution, and the earlier caution should not be inflated into a rejection of the entire player.
Mellody’s existing website profile describes a midfield/defensive role. For a draft exercise, that raises a useful question about how a club wants to move the ball and which role a young player could develop into. The stream’s opinion is one input to that discussion, rather than a verified forecast of his eventual position or performance.
The stronger objection was to another tall forward
SotaramAFL questioned Spawton-Guy’s fit because West Coast already had several forward options in the list being discussed. The argument concerned the balance of the intake, rather than proof that Spawton-Guy lacks talent. No new injury, contract or selection-status claim is established by that discussion.
Elliott was also a selection SotaramAFL was uncertain about, but the exchange did not develop a detailed scouting case against him. It would be misleading to invent one. Read Elliott’s small-forward profile alongside Spawton-Guy’s tall-forward profile, then decide what each role adds to the particular list you are building.
George Gale was the preferred alternative to explore
SotaramAFL said that Gale reaching a later West Coast selection would be a more appealing possibility. Availability remains the constraint: in the reconstructed board, Port selected Gale before West Coast’s Elliott and Spawton-Guy choices. Changing that outcome therefore requires another club to pass on Gale, a trade, or a different earlier sequence.
A fair comparison keeps those assumptions visible. Save the reconstructed starting position, record West Coast’s three-player haul, and build a separate version in which Gale is available. Compare the full intake and any assets spent to reach him. Restarting until a preferred player falls does not by itself show that the alternative is attainable.
What to take into your own draft
Before making a later pick, name the role you want to add and a second prospect you would accept if the favourite is gone. Compare that choice with the players already drafted and the options on the list. This makes the disagreement about a tall forward something you can test, rather than a simple approval or rejection of one name.
The app may now use a different starting order or matching setup. The simulator link opens the tool, without loading the historical save. SotaramAFL’s earlier completed community board remains separately published on the main written mock-draft page; the reported top-30 reconstruction and later reset experiment are labelled independently.
Follow the prospects and club options
Heath Mellody · Archie Elliott · Harvey Spawton-Guy · George Gale
Read the current written 2026 AFL mock draft, the bidding guide or check the points calculator.
Make your own AFL mock draft ↗Simulator walkthrough →
Sources: video dates and timestamps
Sources are SotaramAFL’s completed “AFL MOCK DRAFT LIVE! You Choose The Picks!” livestreams. Dates refer to broadcasts; this article was published on 17 November.
- 17 November 2026 · 0:18 — The stream introduces Cal Twomey’s phantom as the board being reviewed
- 17 November 2026 · 4:00 — Early reservations about the Mellody selection
- 17 November 2026 · 15:57 — Elliott and Spawton-Guy entered into the reconstructed board
- 17 November 2026 · 23:39 — Whole-haul assessment, the tall-forward question and Gale alternative
Automatic transcripts were used as review aids and checked against video frames and prospect records. The 17 November audio was transcribed locally because YouTube captions were unavailable; the final 15 November board was checked separately. Other chat suggestions use generic attribution when an exact displayed public username was not verified. Current app settings may produce different results.
More from the livestreams
Richmond’s draft choice: Butler first or Van Hattum?
Compare Richmond’s November livestream scenarios: why SotaramAFL preferred Van Hattum first, and how a later traded pick produced Butler, Teixeira and Van Hattum.
Read the analysis →GWS, Matthews and Steed: what trading for pick 12 changes
Follow two separate GWS scenarios from SotaramAFL’s 15 November live: Matthews before Steed, Steed before Matthews, and the Port pick-12 trade behind them.
Read the analysis →A viewer’s three-way trade: Richmond, Port and Gold Coast
Unpack @matttigers791’s livestream trade proposal: Richmond splits pick 2, Port moves up for a Cochrane match, and Gold Coast adds a 2028 second.
Read the analysis →