A viewer’s three-way trade: Richmond, Port and Gold Coast
@matttigers791’s proposal split Richmond’s pick 2 into 7 and 8, moved Port to 2 and gave Gold Coast a future second for sliding to 12. The interesting part was Port’s post-bid hand; equal-looking pick value alone did not explain the outcome.
Context: analysis of simulated selections and hypothetical trades, not agreed club deals or confirmed recruitment intentions.
| Club | Sends | Receives |
|---|---|---|
| Richmond | Pick 2 and Richmond’s 2028 second-round pick | Picks 7 and 8 |
| Port Adelaide | Picks 7 and 12 | Pick 2 |
| Gold Coast | Pick 8 | Pick 12 and Richmond’s 2028 second-round pick |
The proposal came from the live chat
The full package appeared on screen during the 12 November livestream under the public username @matttigers791. SotaramAFL worked through the suggestion, executed it in the simulator and later saved it for further discussion. The table above preserves the proposed starting pick numbers and the specified 2028 second; those are not numbers from the board after bids have moved it.
On 15 November, SotaramAFL revisited the three-way idea and explicitly credited a viewer while saying the contributor’s name had been forgotten. The visible 12 November message provides the attribution. This is a community proposal explored on stream, with no claim that the clubs discussed or agreed to it.
Richmond: turn one early choice into two
Richmond gives up the earliest open choice in the package and a future second, in exchange for two early selections. SotaramAFL’s immediate assessment was that a cluster of early picks could make sense for a rebuilding list. The cost is giving other clubs the first chance at preferred prospects, alongside the lost future asset.
The trade therefore makes most sense if Richmond sees enough similarly appealing players around its new choices. It becomes harder to justify if one standout target would be lost by moving back. The livestream’s discussion of Butler and Van Hattum shows why that availability question matters.
Port: the surviving pick matters more than pick 2’s label
For Port, moving from 7 and 12 to 2 was not presented as a way to take an unrelated player before Cochrane. SotaramAFL tested the hand against a Cochrane bid at 1. The question was what remained after paying for the match.
In the executed 12 November experiment, Port still needed to use pick 22 in the match, and that part of the hand became a pick around 30 afterwards. SotaramAFL compared this with the separate Sydney-swap experiment’s returned pick around 49. These were two simulated outcomes with different inputs, rather than two entitlements that Port could combine.
The lesson is to inspect the post-match order. A higher starting pick can produce a different remainder even when the tied prospect stays the same. A trade calculator’s headline balance does not show that whole sequence on its own.
Gold Coast: accept a later choice for future value
Gold Coast moves from 8 to 12 and receives Richmond’s 2028 second. That is the clearest immediate-versus-future exchange in the proposal. The attraction depends on whether Gold Coast expects an acceptable player at the later pick and how it values a selection two drafts away.
SotaramAFL raised the delay in accessing that future player when revisiting the idea. The stream’s package is therefore best read as a negotiation question: what would make sliding back worthwhile for Gold Coast? The fact that the simulator can execute the exchange does not establish club acceptance or AFL approval.
Keep this experiment separate from the final mock draft
The final 15 November board used a different Richmond–Gold Coast trade, alongside the Sydney–Port swap and GWS’s move for pick 12. Do not use the three-way proposal’s asset table to explain that final board. They are separate runs with different starting ownership.
To explore the three-way idea yourself, save a baseline, enter the three clubs’ proposed assets, then run the Cochrane bid and compare the remaining hands. Track both the available players now and the future selections spent. The simulator link opens the app; it does not automatically load this historical save.
Follow the prospects and club options
Dougie Cochrane · Arki Butler · Harry Van Hattum
Richmond · Port Adelaide · Gold Coast
Read the current written 2026 AFL mock draft, the bidding guide or check the points calculator.
Make your own AFL mock draft ↗Simulator walkthrough →
Sources: video dates and timestamps
Sources are SotaramAFL’s completed “AFL MOCK DRAFT LIVE! You Choose The Picks!” livestreams. Dates refer to broadcasts; this article was published on 17 November.
- 12 November 2026 · 42:45 — @matttigers791’s public username and full proposal on screen
- 12 November 2026 · 44:42 — SotaramAFL works through all three clubs
- 12 November 2026 · 45:39 — Executed experiment and Port’s post-match pick
- 15 November 2026 · 1:13:06 — SotaramAFL revisits the saved viewer proposal
Automatic transcripts were used as review aids and checked against video frames and prospect records. The 17 November audio was transcribed locally because YouTube captions were unavailable; the final 15 November board was checked separately. @matttigers791 is credited from the public username and proposal visible at 42:45 on 12 November. Current app settings may produce different results.
More from the livestreams
Richmond’s draft choice: Butler first or Van Hattum?
Compare Richmond’s November livestream scenarios: why SotaramAFL preferred Van Hattum first, and how a later traded pick produced Butler, Teixeira and Van Hattum.
Read the analysis →GWS, Matthews and Steed: what trading for pick 12 changes
Follow two separate GWS scenarios from SotaramAFL’s 15 November live: Matthews before Steed, Steed before Matthews, and the Port pick-12 trade behind them.
Read the analysis →West Coast’s draft options: Mellody, Elliott and the tall-forward question
SotaramAFL reacts to West Coast’s haul while reconstructing Cal Twomey’s top 30: Mellody, Elliott, Spawton-Guy, and George Gale as a preferred alternative.
Read the analysis →